I would add to this brilliant observation by Kevin Deanna over at Takimag.com that conservatives stand to gain more in the years to come by the teenagers, young folks and other “weirdos” (as the mainstream conservative media liked to paint them) who were energized by the Ron Paul campaign this election than anything coming out of groups like YAF. These formerly apolitical, or even self-described Lefties, have latched on to small government, anti-imperialism in some of their most intellectually formative years, and as we politicos well know, it only takes a few sometimes to create and continue revolution.
Writes Kevin Deanna:
“A small piece of me died inside when I read Kathryn Jean Lopez’s assurance that “the future is bright” from the looks of the aspiring apparatchiks at the Young America’s Foundation conference. Having received reports of my own from attendees and confident in my own qualifications to speak on the state of the young conservative “movement,” I have to give my own opinion.
The largest problem with the youth “movement” is that it is encouraging people to believe that political action is the struggle to advance through the ranks of the established conservative infrastructure. Bringing various conservative celebrities to campus or attending conferences may be entertaining or even educational, but does little to actually retake power on college campuses. Even if the group raises the necessary tens of thousands of dollars to bring Ann Coulter to campus, the overall dynamic of domination by tenured leftists, various multicultural fiefdoms, and the approved radicalism of groups like SDS remains unchanged. There is a serious problem when students can bring people like Ron Paul, Tom Tancredo, Grover Norquist, Karl Rove, and Sam Brownback to campus—and like them all equally. There is far too much focus on access to famous people rather than accomplishing anything useful or really exploring the importance of ideas.
Now, Young America’s Foundation and other institutions (like the one I work for) are useful, and do need to exist, but let’s not kid ourselves that they are anything close to sufficient. Nor is there a “conservative revolution” occurring on college campuses anymore than there was a “Reagan Revolution” that actually limited the growth of the state or reversed the culture war. The last thing we need are conservative students raising more polite suggestions for “diversity of ideas” to contemptuous and bemused campus commissars or serving as cannon fodder for John McCain.
Young conservative activists have more to learn from Saul Alinsky than Ed Meese. While Lopez “kept her shades close by” to shield her from the bright future, I can only look away from what resembles something more like a dark nightmare of years of failed strategy. If we actually want to win this thing, and not just congratulate ourselves on who we have had our picture taken with, we need to recognize that.”
One Comment
When wealthy paleoconservatives are willing to produce controversial movies, when they are willing to finance publishing houses other than stuffed shirt Regnery Gateway, then the movement will succeed. When young paleos are willing to shout themselves hoarse demonstrating, when they are willing to get themselves arrested blocking sidewalks, then the movement will succeed. When they tire of turning the other cheek, when they will not be silenced by smear stereotypes, when they stop apologizing for the Richard Wagners and H.L. Menckens, then the movement will succeed. When they promote the memory of the Nikola Teslas and Edwin Armstrongs as relentlessly as the enemy promotes the memory of the Albert Einsteins and David Sarnoffs, then the movement will succeed. When they have made the Bolsheviks as much a household word as the Nazis, when the famine in the Ukraine is as well known as Auschwitz, then the movement will succeed. When names like Wolfowitz, Perle and Fleischer are on everyone’s tongues, then the movement will succeed. When all Americans are familiar with the cryptic message, “The bride is beautiful, but she belongs to another man,” then the movement will succeed. When they will denounce the Rockefeller Family from the rooftops, then the movement will succeed. Alas, they are conservative, and so they fail.